Find Delicious Pies for Your Holiday Meal in Spartanburg and Greenville, SC

Posted on | No Comments

Wondering where you can purchase a fabulous pie for your holiday meal? Greenville and Spartanburg restaurants are offering some delicious holiday pie options. Plus, our readers chimed in with their favorite local pies to help you fill your holiday dessert table!

holiday pies

Fill your table with amazing food for the holidays from local restaurants, cafes, bakeries, and more. We have full meals, desserts, sides, charcuterie, take-home kits and so much more! Here’s all the amazing holiday food available to order for Thanksgiving from restaurants in Spartanburg, and Thanksgiving from restaurants in Greenville. Our 2022 lists are coming soon!

Ordering Pies For The Holidays

Are you looking for an easier way to celebrate the holidays? This year has been 36 months long, and I don’t know about you but rolling out fresh pie crust is just about the last thing I want to do. 

Don’t get me wrong. I still want to eat pie, just not have to cut, chop, mix, bake, and clean to get that yummy bite of pie. Thankfully, Greenville has a bunch of places willing to step up to the plate and do the work for me (and anyone else). 

Pumpkin, Custard, Pecan, or fruit-filled- there’s a local bakery with a pie just waiting to be invited to your family meal! 

Where To Buy a Pie In Spartanburg, SC

Blue Moon Specialty Foods

Not only can you enjoy a pie from Blue Moon specialty foods, but they’ll also prepare your whole entire meal! They have a huge selection of items to choose from for your holiday meal, including these pies.

Blue Moon Holiday Order Form

  • Chocolate Chess Pie (Chocolate custard with a hint of raspberry) – $19.99
  • Hub Derby Pie (Chocolate Chip & Pecans) – $22.95
  • Buttermilk Pie – $19.99
  • Lemon Chess Pie (Lemon custard) – $19.99
  • French Silk Pie – $19.99
  • Pecan Pie – $22.95
  • Marbled Pumpkin Pie – $19.99

Wade’s Southern Cooking

A staple for a lot of Spartanburg residents, Wade’s has been invited to many holiday meals! They are very popular during the holidays, so make sure you check out the holiday ordering facts sheet online before you head that way.

  • Derby Pie, Pecan Pie, Lemon, Peanut Butter Pie – $13.99
  • French Silk Pie – $19.99

Where to Buy a Pie in Greenville, SC

Bossy Bakers

Make sure you place your order in advance if you want to claim one of these unique scratch-made pies from Bossy Bakers!

Bossy Bakers on Wade Hampton! They’re made with high quality ingredients and simply delicious!

Teresa H.
  • Black Bottom Pumpkin Pie – $31
  • Burnt Caramel Pear Pie – $33
  • Chocolate Chess Pie – $29
  • Apple Bourbon Pecan Pie – $35

Carolina Bourbon Belles

Carolina Bourbon Belles is a favorite with Kidding Around readers, this bakery was mentioned several times on social media when we polled our readers.

Carolina Bourbon Belles = Deliciousness!!

Jennifer R.W.
  • Bourbon Apple Pie – $36.95
  • Chocolate Bourbon Chess Pie – $34.95
  • Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie – $34.95+
  • Bourbon Chess Pie – $34.95

Hester General Store

Hester General Store in Easley is offering Holiday Pies, available through pre-order. They’ll be offering a variety of pies and pastries specially themed for the holidays, including a signature lemon meringue pie.

holiday pie

Green Tomato Buffet

Green Tomato Buffet in Greenville offers catering options that include pies, cakes, and other desserts! The pies are $12 each and flavors include:

  • Pumpkin
  • Sweet Potato
  • German Chocolate
  • Egg Custard
  • Butter Coconut
  • Lemon Chess

Strossner’s

Strossner’s  gets really busy during the holidays, so you need to get that order in early if you want them on your holiday table.

  • Fruit Pies -$16
  • Dutch Apple – $18
  • Pecan, Chocolate Pecan Bourbon – $18
  • Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream Pie – $18

Swamp Rabbit Cafe and Grocery

You could find everything you need to pull off a spectacular holiday meal at Swamp Rabbit Cafe! They even offer gluten-free pie crust, so that everyone can enjoy some dessert! If you haven’t tried chocolate chess, you’re missing out. 

Swamp Rabbit Cafe – Fresh local ingredients and delicious! I think they usually host a pie tasting and oh man that sounds good

Kerry M.M.
  • Streusel Apple, Bourbon Pecan, Chocolate Chess, *Brown Sugar Whiskey, and Pumpkin Pie offered in both traditional and gluten-free versions, starting at $28

*Not available Gluten-Free

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop specializes in pies, and we’ve heard only good things! Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop would be a great place to stop if you need an assortment of pies for the holiday season.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has individual mini pies of a variety of flavors!!!

Crystal L.
  • Buttermilk, Pumpkin, Chocolate Chip, Granny Apple, Coconut Custard, I-40, Key Lime, Peanut Butter Cream, Pumpkin, Banana Cream, or Pecan Pie – $26

Kidding Around Team Members
About the Author
How does Kidding Around® bring readers high-quality and up-to-date content month after month and season after season? We have a dedicated team of writers and editors who regularly update our fabulous content to keep it current and relevant for our readers. This team combs lists of events, heads out into the community to experience new Upstate offerings, and communicates with local businesses. Many of our updated articles and event lists, like this one, reflect the contributions and hard work of multiple Kidding Around® team members.

Sign up for our email newsletter.

Comments are closed.