Wondering where you can purchase the best pies near Greenville, SC for your holiday meal?
Greenville and Spartanburg restaurants are offering some delicious holiday pie options. Plus, our readers chimed in with their favorite local pies to help you fill your holiday dessert table!
Ordering Pies For The Holidays
Are you looking for an easier way to celebrate the holidays? This year has been 36 months long, and, I don’t know about you, but rolling out fresh pie crust is just about the last thing I want to do, even if it means homemade pies.
Don’t get me wrong. I still want to eat pie, just not have to cut, chop, mix, bake, and clean to get that yummy bite of pie. Thankfully, Greenville has a bunch of places willing to step up to the plate and do the work for me (and anyone else).
Pumpkin, Custard, Pecan, or fruit-filled- there’s a local bakery with a pie just waiting to be invited to your family meal!
Where To Buy a Pie In Spartanburg, SC
Blue Moon Specialty Foods
Not only can you enjoy a pie from Blue Moon specialty foods, but they’ll also prepare your whole entire meal! They have a huge selection of items to choose from for your holiday meal, including these pies.
Blue Moon Thanksgiving Pre-Order Form
Pre-order by Wednesday, November 18, then pick up at the Blue Moon Bodega (220 E Daniel Morgan Ave, Spartanburg) on Tuesday, November 24 (12–7 PM) or Wednesday, November 25 (8 AM–4 PM). Prefer to order by phone? Call 864-308-1439.
- Chocolate Chess Pie (with a hint of raspberry) – $19.99
- Lemon Chess Pie (custard pie with a bright citrus flavor) – $19.99
- Buttermilk Pie – $19.99
- Marbled Pumpkin Pie (with a cream cheese swirl) – $19.99
- Apple Pie (topped with house streusel) – $22.99
- Hub Derby Pie (chocolate chips, pecans, and a hint of bourbon) – $22.99
- French Silk Pie (with pecans lining the crust) – $22.99
- Pecan Pie – $24.99
Wade’s Southern Cooking
A staple for a lot of Spartanburg residents, Wade’s has been invited to many holiday meals! They are very popular during the holidays, so make sure you check out the holiday ordering facts sheet online before you head that way. Wade’s doesn’t take holiday pre-orders: its frozen pies are sold year-round, and holiday items are first come, first served while supplies last, so shop early.
- Derby Pie, Pecan Pie, Lemon, Peanut Butter Pie – $14.99
- French Silk Pie – $21.99
Where to Buy a Pie in Greenville, SC
Ready to purchase holiday pies? Greenville, SC has quite a few options.
Green Tomato Buffet
Green Tomato Buffet in Greenville offers catering options that include pies, cakes, and other desserts! Pie prices aren’t posted online, so call (864) 281-0377 for current pricing. The catering menu notes that orders “must be placed within 24 hours of pick up,” with 50% due when you order. Flavors include:
- Pumpkin
- Sweet Potato
- German Chocolate
- Egg Custard
- Butter Coconut
- Lemon Chess
Strossner’s
Strossner’s gets really busy during the holidays, so you need to get that order in early if you want them on your holiday table.
- Fruit Pies (Apple, Cherry, Blueberry, Peach, Strawberry Rhubarb) – $22
- Dutch Apple – $22
- Pecan, Chocolate Bourbon Pecan – $25
- Chocolate Cream, Coconut Cream Pie – $25
Swamp Rabbit Cafe and Grocery
You could find everything you need to pull off a spectacular holiday meal at Swamp Rabbit Cafe! They even offer gluten-free pie crust, so that everyone can enjoy some dessert! If you haven’t tried chocolate chess, you’re missing out.
Swamp Rabbit Cafe – Fresh local ingredients and delicious! I think they usually host a pie tasting and oh man that sounds good
Kerry M.M.- Chocolate Chess, Apple with Streusel Topping, and Pecan pies – $30–$32 (gluten-free option available)
- Pumpkin Cream Pie (gluten-free) – $30
- Pumpkin Cheesecake with graham-cracker crust (gluten-free, serves 4) – $22
Swamp Rabbit Thanksgiving preorders close Friday, November 20, with pickup Saturday, November 21 through Wednesday, November 25 at 205 Cedar Lane Rd.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop specializes in pies, and we’ve heard only good things! Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop would be a great place to stop if you need an assortment of pies for the holiday season. 9″ pies are $32 each ($34 for gluten-friendly versions) on the shop’s online ordering menu.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop has individual mini pies of a variety of flavors!!!
Crystal L.The Southern Growl
The Southern Growl, just up the road in Greer (155 N Buncombe Rd), has Thanksgiving dessert covered with their Pecan Pie Cake, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Hokkaido Rolls, and take and bake cinnamon rolls.
Rise Bakery
Rise Bakery in West Greenville (1264 Pendleton St) is taking holiday preorders for 10″ pies that serve 8, baked in an all-butter sourdough multigrain crust. Preorder by November 20 and choose pickup on Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25.
- Brown Butter Pumpkin Pie – $32
- Bourbon Pecan Pie – $35
Sweet Bites Bakery
Need a pie that works for guests with food allergies? Sweet Bites Bakery makes vegan and allergen-free desserts, including gluten-free pies and a vegan Thanksgiving dessert menu. The bakery asks for 72 hours’ notice, and orders are pickup-only from its kitchen at 339-A Miller Rd in Mauldin.
- Vegan Mile High Apple Pie (gluten-free) – $69.99
- Vegan Bean Pie (gluten-free) – $59.99
What’s your favorite kind of pie?
Fill your table with amazing food for the holidays from local restaurants, cafes, bakeries, and more. We have full meals, desserts, sides, charcuterie, take-home kits, and so much more! Here’s all the amazing holiday food available to order for Thanksgiving from restaurants in Spartanburg, and Thanksgiving from restaurants in Greenville. Our lists are being updated regularly!
Looking for more fun things to do for Thanksgiving? We’ve got everything you need to know about celebrating Thanksgiving around Greenville and Spartanburg, SC.
