10+ Bakers Making Custom Cookies Near Greenville, SC

Posted on | 2 Comments

Are you looking for the perfect treat that will have your family in awe of your superpower ability of finding cool custom cookies for your next party or celebration? The Greenville and Spartanburg custom cookie bakers can be your secret weapon. We’ve hunted down the local talent who can give you these tiny, unique, and edible works of art, no matter the occasion. See who our readers recommend for your custom cookie needs.

Looking for more great ways to celebrate birthdays in Greenville? Don’t miss Kidding Around’s Ultimate Guide to Birthdays near Greenville.

Custom Cookies, Wild Blueberry Mermaid cookies
Wild Blueberry custom cookies

It’s no secret that custom decorated sugar cookies are works of art and can wow any crowd. They’re not just regular cookies—they’re cool cookies.

Painstakingly decorated by hand, these cookies take time, patience, and talent to produce. Hand-cut out of sugar cookie dough and decorated with royal icing, these cookies can even be frozen if you need to hold on to them for a bit before giving them out. 

And we can’t think of a better way to wow your guests or cookie recipient.

Cookies from Wild Blueberry Bakeshop
Wild Blueberry Bakeshop

We talked with a local cookie artisan Kate Risher of Wild Blueberry Bakeshop, to find out why she does what she does.

KA: Kate, How did you get started?

Kate: I started decorating cookies in 2013. For some reason I decided to try and make royal icing decorated cookies for a camping trip we were taking with friends in the summer. I think I might have seen them on Pinterest which was super popular around that time. I had always enjoyed baking and art so figured why not? I put a picture of those cookies up on Facebook and the caption read “I could get addicted to this!” And we now know that definitely happened! At the time, I was still a chemical engineer working at a plant in Spartanburg. I made cookies for friends and family and sold a few to co-workers but nothing too crazy. When my son was born in February 2016, I decided to be a stay-at-home mom. In September 2016, I decided to officially start my business. I’ve steadily grown since then and have loved every minute of it.

KA: What’s your favorite part of making these little works of art?

Kate: I love seeing people’s faces when they see their cookies! As far as the process, my favorite part is adding all the details and seeing the set come together

KA: What would someone be surprised to know about you or your business?

Kate: I think most people are surprised that I am actually a chemical engineer by trade and am completely self-taught.

Wild Blueberry Bakeshop
Simpsonville, SC | 864.688.9160

Greenville Custom Cookie Bakers Recommended By Readers

We recently asked readers where they go for these almost too-good to eat treats, and they offered up these suggestions.

Amanda Mae’s Sweets

Abbey Kay’s Southern Baked Goods

Abbey Kay’s Southern Baked Goods is AMAZING!! Her cookie game is 🔥

Alisa L

Britishkneecookies 

I’ve gotten my kid’s birthday cookies from her and they are adorable!!!

Lori B

Emily Faye Cookies

Emily Faye Cookies and they also have classes to learn to make your own!

Becki M

Marley & Magnolia Bakery

was at a mini farmers market a few weeks ago for my ‘hood and her cookies were so cute

Merideth

Morgan’s Cookie Company

Her cookies are not only pretty but delicious!

Nicole N

Rhapsody Baking LLC

Everything she makes is gorgeous!

Melissa W

Tiny Delights

Joanna Lyn is the BEST at what she does. I wish I had photos of the cookies she made for my sons birthday. I won’t order from anyone else now!

Kelsie Connelly

The Cookie Bee

The Cookie Bee cutest cookies ever!

Christie V

Spartanburg Custom Cookie Bakers Recommended By Readers

Red Cottage Cookies

Amazing Art Work – Cookies and Cakes

Etta Edge

Bee Happy Cakes and Confections

Erin is absolutely amazing! I always use her for any cookie needs! She’s made cookies for me for birthdays, wedding showers, employee appreciation, and bachelorette parties!

Amanda T.

Custom Creations By Leslie

Lesley is awesome!!! We have used her for all of our Birthdays for the last 3 years!!! Will not use anyone else for custom creations!! Not only is her work BEAUTIFUL, it’s also soooooo delicious!!!

Kristen M.

Jelly Designs Bakes

Jelly Bakes Designs! She is awesome and also does take home kits every once in a while. She also does dog treats! Gluten free is also an option from her.

Zanada R.

Kellybakes

She is phenomenal always creates the best designs to go with whatever theme I throw her way, pretty sure it’s everyone’s favorite thing to take home from out birthday parties!!!

Jessica Elizabeth Halford

Knight Owl Cookie Company

Used her for my sister’s bachelorette, they Friends themed cookies were BEAUTIFUL & tasty!

Ashley Turner Prysock

Liz Made Cookies

Oh Sweets By Hannah

Not only does she decorate beautifully, she does cookie kits for holidays so the kids can decorate their own too.

Samantha C.

Smithery Sweets

Smithery Sweets is amazing

Erin Wease

Consider these little pieces of art for your next event or just to show someone you care. Better yet, treat yourself! Whatever the occasion, remember that they are meant to be eaten, so don’t feel bad for taking a bite out of one of them.

Kidding Around Team Members
About the Author
How does Kidding Around® bring readers high-quality and up-to-date content month after month and season after season? We have a dedicated team of writers and editors who regularly update our fabulous content to keep it current and relevant for our readers. This team combs lists of events, heads out into the community to experience new Upstate offerings, and communicates with local businesses. Many of our updated articles and event lists, like this one, reflect the contributions and hard work of multiple Kidding Around® team members.

Sign up for our email newsletter.

Subscribe
Notify of
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

I’d love to be on this list!

Deborah
2 years ago

That Sweets Chick also makes great cookies that look amazing and taste great. Give her a try.